The Global Think Tank - Click here to learn more...

Forget Greece, it's China

Moisés Naím El Pais, October 3, 2011 Comments

While the world's attention remains glued to the crisis in Greece (population 11 million), in China (population 1.34 billion) things are going on that we are mistakenly overlooking. Should the world's economic engine stall, the consequences would be much more serious than any Greek problem, even taking into account its impact on the wider European economy. Here are a few boring facts about what is happening in China: manufacturing has fallen for the third consecutive month; the construction boom is about to bust; property prices are falling, and companies in the sector are finding it hard to access financing. Local government debt is now equivalent to 27 percent of the economy, and experts say that 80 of that debt cannot be recovered. Share prices of Chinese companies on the New York Stock Exchange fell on the news that regulators found serious faults in their accounts.

The Financial Times' summary is a little less boring: "A sector that was until last year the darling of international investors is turning into a horror show [...] a development that would send shockwaves through financial markets worldwide."

Does this mean that China is headed for a crash? Not necessarily. But there is a strong possibility that China's economic growth is set to be derailed. The accident could be financial, environmental, social, or international. A collapse on the stock exchange that would wipe out people's savings, or some kind of infrastructure disaster that would prompt millions to take to the streets in protest, could be the spark that sets off a crisis that would eventually hit the economy. And that would then quickly spread around the world.

The social and political contract the Chinese Communist Party has with the people reads like this: we create millions of jobs and promise continued prosperity for you and you let us govern without you playing any part in the process. If job creation stutters so does the regime's legitimacy, and its ability to govern centrally as it has until now. There are other factors at play as well that could have dangerous political consequences: inflation, inequality, and corruption. Over the last decade, inflation has rarely risen above two percent a year. It is now at 6.2 percent, while food prices, the most politically explosive factor, have risen even higher.

Inequality before the boom was limited, and invisible to most people. It is now among the worst in the world. Urban workers earn three times more than peasants in rural areas, and the number of Chinese people among the wealthiest in the world breaks new records every year, while China's millionaires are, on average, around 15 years younger than those in other countries. Corruption has long been a problem, but it is now increasingly widespread, and far more visible, and affects almost all areas of life. The government has tried to stem the flow of graft. But highly publicized jail terms and even the death sentence for public officials are simply not working.

Economic crises tend to turn corruption from an irritation that can largely be put up with, even over long periods of time, into a powerful popular cause that rallies the population. We should remember that corruption was a determining factor in the downfall of the previous regimes in Tunisia and Egypt. The same applies as regards mounting environmental problems, which for many Chinese are not merely abstract issues. After a while, people get tired of turning on the tap to take a bath or make a cup of tea only to find that brown, foul-smelling water comes out. According to Sun Liping, a sociologist at Tsinghua University, there were 180,000 street protests against a multitude of issues in 2010. The Chinese are increasingly prepared to take to the streets to demand their rights. If this kind of activity starts to impact the economy, then what happens in China will affect us all, and much more than what is going on in Greece.

 

Comments (1)

 
  • Alex 7:15 AM October 14, 2011
    Yes it's true
  • Report Abuse
Resources available for this publication
Source: www.carnegieendowment.org/publications/index.cfm?fa=view&id=45673
Featured Event
Wednesday, October 5, 2011 Brussels

Europe’s Crisis, China’s Opportunity

Beijing’s relationship with Europe is increasingly complex, with a number of economic arrangements that could compromise European ideals.

More Related Events
Related Publications
 

Carnegie Resources

Quotes on Carnegie - Praise for the Global Think Tank
“[Carnegie is]…one of the centers of gravity of thinking about national security matters in our country.” – General Martin Dempsey, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
“Carnegie remains a first-rate source of policy analysis and practical guidance on all the major international issues and I rely on the advice and counsel of many Carnegie scholars.” – John McCain, U.S. Senator
“The Carnegie Endowment has been a training ground for many of the all-stars in the State Department….” – Madeleine Albright, Former Secretary of State
“I appreciate its work in the area of peace.” – Kofi Annan, Former Secretary-General of the United Nations
“I cannot think of a better alignment of communication, information, and getting people together.” – Eric Schmidt, Executive Chairman of Google
“The Carnegie Endowment for International Peace is the #3 think tank in the world.” University of Pennsylvania 2011 Global Think Tank Rankings
“[T]his great vision of becoming a global think tank [is] badly needed in an interconnected world.” – Nicholas Burns, Undersecretary of State for Political Affairs
“One of the most globally trusted talking-shops.” The Economist
“The Carnegie Endowment for International Peace is the #3 think tank in the United States.” University of Pennsylvania 2011 Global Think Tank Rankings
“It is truly a global think tank…completely and appropriately reflective of the nature of the challenges that we face today.” – John Kerry, U.S. Senator
“A force for global peace and security for 100 years.” – John Brennan, Homeland Security Advisor
“An excellent institution that does important work to help establish stronger international laws and organizations.” – His Royal Highness Prince Turki Al-Faisal
“The Carnegie Moscow Center is the top think tank in Central and Eastern Europe.” University of Pennsylvania 2011 Global Think Tank Rankings
“The Carnegie Endowment…has for a century been dedicated to understanding and preventing war and its myriad causes.” – Robert Gates, U.S. Secretary of Defense
“The Carnegie Endowment is known on both sides of the aisle with great deal of respect for your active international engagement….” – Michael Turner, U.S. Congressman
“[This event is]… a testament to the success that you’ve had in transforming Carnegie… into a truly global think tank.” – Leon Panetta, U.S. Secretary of Defense
“The Carnegie Middle East Center is the top think tank in the Middle East and North Africa.” University of Pennsylvania 2011 Global Think Tank Rankings

From Carnegie's Global Network

Lebanon Edges Closer to Syrian Crisis

Paul Salem
Thursday, May 17, 2012

As armed clashes last weekend show, north Lebanon is becoming a growing support base for the Syrian revolution. Sunni mobilization in support of the uprising in Syria is mounting and the Lebanese government is losing its ability to maintain its policy of neutrality.

Future Challenges for U.S.-China Relations

Michael D. Swaine, Yan Xuetong, Paul Haenle, John Pomfret, Yuan Peng
Tuesday, April 17, 2012

The U.S. pivot to the Asia-Pacific has created both tension and opportunity in its relations with China.

In Germany, Divide on Left Is Transparent

Judy Dempsey
Tuesday, May 15, 2012

The success of Germany's Pirates party is the result of its transparency and accountability. Sustaining that enthusiasm through national elections in 2013 will be a challenge, however.

What Should We Expect During Putin’s Third Term?

Mykola Siruk, Lilia Shevtsova
Tuesday, May 15, 2012

Putin has returned to the Kremlin, but he faces a significantly different Russia, because the country's situation has changed drastically. The previous Putin’s consensus between those in power and society has fallen apart.

Connect with Carnegie

Stay in the Know

Sign up for Carnegie announcements and publications—including Carnegie This Week—by filling out the form below. Note—fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

Personal Information
 
 
 
1779 Massachusetts Ave. NW Washington, DC 20036-2103 Phone: 202 483 7600 Fax: 202 483 1840