The Global Think Tank - Click here to learn more...

Egypt: Is There a Way Forward?

Marina Ottaway, Bahgat Korany Friday, December 2, 2011 – Washington, D.C.

Facing a reinvigorated protest movement and multiple rounds of elections, Egypt is in the middle of a critical stage of its transition with no agreement among political forces about what the next steps should be. Egypt’s Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) lost popularity after a harsh crackdown on mass protests in Cairo and other major cities on November 19. At the same time, the Muslim Brotherhood faces the new challenges of maintaining internal unity and building political coalitions after winning big in the first stage of parliamentary elections that began on November 28. 

The American University of Cairo's Bahgat Korany discussed the major challenges facing the country. Carnegie's Marina Ottaway moderated.

Post-Revolutionary Egypt

  • Major Actors: Korany suggested that there are three major political forces in Egypt today: the SCAF and the military; the Islamists; and what he described as the ‘Republic of Facebook,’ the coalition of young liberals, leftists, and workers.
     
  • Future: Although the elections appear to have begun smoothly, there are a number of reasons to be concerned about the future of Egypt, including the deteriorating security situation and the bleak state of economic affairs in the country, Korany stated.

The Military

  • Popularity: The military began this transitional period with widespread prestige because of the restraint it showed by not firing on protesters, as well as the traditional popular attachment to the military, Korany argued. However, this popularity has diminished in the past weeks.
     
  • Mistrust: Korany outlined a number of reasons for growing mistrust of the SCAF: 

    • Elections: Although the security situation in Egypt has been deteriorating since February, the military was able to secure the elections, which led many to believe the military was not acting in the interest of the general population.

    • Old Regime: Its members are viewed as part of the old regime.

    • Economy: The military is widely known to have major economic interests. 

    • Politics: Distrust of the military will naturally increase as the SCAF becomes simply another actor in the political sphere, Korany added. 

The Islamists

  • Commonalities: The Islamists, Korany said, are not a monolithic group, but they do share a high level of organization and presence on the ground that the liberal parties lack. 
     
  • Pragmatism: Korany characterized the Islamist groups, particularly the Muslim Brotherhood’s Freedom and Justice Party, as pragmatic opportunists who did not spearhead the revolution, but are taking advantage of the changes. 
     
  • Potential Challenges: Korany added that the Islamists face two major challenges in the coming months:  controlling the ranks of their groups, particularly the youth, and maintaining unity; and establishing real policies on the critical issues facing Egypt today. 
     
  • Muslim Brotherhood and Salafis: Despite reports that the Freedom and Justice Party was not planning on allying itself with the more conservative Salafi al-Nour party, there is not likely to be a complete break between the two groups, Korany said. There are too many critical issues that the two agree on. 

The Protest Movement

  • Unexpected Success: The ‘Republic of Facebook,’ the coalition of young liberals, leftists, and workers who initiated the January 2011 uprising, did not anticipate that the protests would grow as strong as they did and were surprised by their own success, Korany said. 
     
  • Primary Characteristics: Korany characterized this group as idealistic and determined, but lacking experience and an on-the-ground presence outside of Egypt’s urban centers. Their primary goals are gender equality, human rights, and democratization. 
     
  • Potential Challenges: Like the military and the Islamists, this group faces a number of significant challenges, Korany said, including the need to bridge the generational and rural-urban divides that separate them from significant portions of the Egyptian populace and the need to avoid becoming marginalized after the elections when the new parliament establishes a decision-making mechanism that bypasses Tahrir Square. 

 

 
Source: www.carnegieendowment.org/events/?fa=eventDetail&id=3466
Featured Publication
Commentary, November 3, 2011

Egypt’s Democracy: Between the Military, Islamists, and Illiberal Democrats

Unless the Islamists and liberals can find a way to coexist in Egyptian politics, Egypt risks falling into a new authoritarianism, with the military and the liberals undermining the democratic process to prevent Islamist participation.

More Related Publications...
Related Events
 

Carnegie Resources

Quotes on Carnegie - Praise for the Global Think Tank
“[Carnegie is]…one of the centers of gravity of thinking about national security matters in our country.” – General Martin Dempsey, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
“Carnegie remains a first-rate source of policy analysis and practical guidance on all the major international issues and I rely on the advice and counsel of many Carnegie scholars.” – John McCain, U.S. Senator
“The Carnegie Endowment has been a training ground for many of the all-stars in the State Department….” – Madeleine Albright, Former Secretary of State
“I appreciate its work in the area of peace.” – Kofi Annan, Former Secretary-General of the United Nations
“I cannot think of a better alignment of communication, information, and getting people together.” – Eric Schmidt, Executive Chairman of Google
“The Carnegie Endowment for International Peace is the #3 think tank in the world.” University of Pennsylvania 2011 Global Think Tank Rankings
“[T]his great vision of becoming a global think tank [is] badly needed in an interconnected world.” – Nicholas Burns, Undersecretary of State for Political Affairs
“One of the most globally trusted talking-shops.” The Economist
“The Carnegie Endowment for International Peace is the #3 think tank in the United States.” University of Pennsylvania 2011 Global Think Tank Rankings
“It is truly a global think tank…completely and appropriately reflective of the nature of the challenges that we face today.” – John Kerry, U.S. Senator
“A force for global peace and security for 100 years.” – John Brennan, Homeland Security Advisor
“An excellent institution that does important work to help establish stronger international laws and organizations.” – His Royal Highness Prince Turki Al-Faisal
“The Carnegie Moscow Center is the top think tank in Central and Eastern Europe.” University of Pennsylvania 2011 Global Think Tank Rankings
“The Carnegie Endowment…has for a century been dedicated to understanding and preventing war and its myriad causes.” – Robert Gates, U.S. Secretary of Defense
“The Carnegie Endowment is known on both sides of the aisle with great deal of respect for your active international engagement….” – Michael Turner, U.S. Congressman
“[This event is]… a testament to the success that you’ve had in transforming Carnegie… into a truly global think tank.” – Leon Panetta, U.S. Secretary of Defense
“The Carnegie Middle East Center is the top think tank in the Middle East and North Africa.” University of Pennsylvania 2011 Global Think Tank Rankings

From Carnegie's Global Network

Syrian Regime Cannot Conceal An Economy in Rapid Decline

Ibrahim Saif
Tuesday, May 22, 2012

No one is fully knowledgeable about the state of the Syrian economy, how exactly it has been affected by the events taking place in the country, or how to interpret the choice economic indicators issued by Syrian officials.

Future Challenges for U.S.-China Relations

Michael D. Swaine, Yan Xuetong, Paul Haenle, John Pomfret, Yuan Peng
Tuesday, April 17, 2012

The U.S. pivot to the Asia-Pacific has created both tension and opportunity in its relations with China.

Saving the Euro without Losing the Europeans

Stefan Lehne
Wednesday, May 23, 2012

Eurozone; Euro Crisis The gap between the efforts to deepen integration in order to save the euro and what most people really think should happen is wider than it has ever been before.

Why I'm Optimistic About Putin's 4th Term

Nikolay Petrov
Monday, May 21, 2012

The Russian political system is likely to undergo some changes this year, perhaps even serious ones — not because Putin wants them, but because elements of Putin's inner circle are convinced that the government must take some of the protesters' demands seriously.

Connect with Carnegie

Stay in the Know

Sign up for Carnegie announcements and publications—including Carnegie This Week—by filling out the form below. Note—fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

Personal Information
 
 
 
1779 Massachusetts Ave. NW Washington, DC 20036-2103 Phone: 202 483 7600 Fax: 202 483 1840